Currently closed for the season. See you in March!

Our Flavors
Our Story
Where to Buy
FAQ

We’ve been making our 50+ homemade flavors right in the back of the shop. Come find your favorite ice cream in a cone, dish, soda, sundae, shake, malt, or float!

OPENING FOR THE SEASON 2/28/26!

COME AND HAVE A CONE WITH US!

Get In Touch!

Latest From Instagram:

Mark your calendars! Our shop will be open on Saturday, February 28th for the 2026 season! We can’t wait to serve you all for another season!
Mark your calendars! Our shop will be open on Saturday, February 28th for the 2026 season! We can’t wait to serve you all for another season!
Come join our crew! Plainwell Ice Cream is now hiring great scoopers for the 2026 season, apply now at plainwellicecream.com! (Link in our bio)
Come join our crew! Plainwell Ice Cream is now hiring great scoopers for the 2026 season, apply now at plainwellicecream.com! (Link in our bio)
We want to thank all of our amazing customers, and our wonderful staff for another great year at Plainwell Ice Cream! We are now closed for the season. It’s been such a fun year and we’re looking forward to many more. See you in the sprin
We want to thank all of our amazing customers, and our wonderful staff for another great year at Plainwell Ice Cream! We are now closed for the season. It’s been such a fun year and we’re looking forward to many more. See you in the spring!
Mark your calendars! Our shop will be open on Saturday, February 28th for the 2026 season! We can’t wait to serve you all for another season! Come join our crew! Plainwell Ice Cream is now hiring great scoopers for the 2026 season, apply now at plainwellicecream.com! (Link in our bio) We want to thank all of our amazing customers, and our wonderful staff for another great year at Plainwell Ice Cream! We are now closed for the season. It’s been such a fun year and we’re looking forward to many more. See you in the sprin