Open Tuesday - Sunday 12–9pm

Closed on Easter Sunday (4/5)

Our Flavors
Our Story
Where to Buy
FAQ

We’ve been making our 50+ homemade flavors right in the back of the shop. Come find your favorite ice cream in a cone, dish, soda, sundae, shake, malt, or float!

OPENING FOR THE SEASON 2/28/26!

COME AND HAVE A CONE WITH US!

Get In Touch!

Latest From Instagram:

Great news!! We finally have Amaretto Chocolate Cherry, for scoops and 1/2 gallons, and S’mores 1/2 gallons are also finally back in stock!
Great news!! We finally have Amaretto Chocolate Cherry, for scoops and 1/2 gallons, and S’mores 1/2 gallons are also finally back in stock!
Say hello to our newest flavor, S’mores! Toasted marshmallow flavored ice cream, graham cracker swirls, and chunks of chocolate! Come grab a scoop or a 1/2 gallon to go!
Say hello to our newest flavor, S’mores! Toasted marshmallow flavored ice cream, graham cracker swirls, and chunks of chocolate! Come grab a scoop or a 1/2 gallon to go!
Welcome to our 49th season at Plainwell Ice Cream, We’re open and ready to serve you!
Welcome to our 49th season at Plainwell Ice Cream, We’re open and ready to serve you!
Great news!! We finally have Amaretto Chocolate Cherry, for scoops and 1/2 gallons, and S’mores 1/2 gallons are also finally back in stock! Say hello to our newest flavor, S’mores! Toasted marshmallow flavored ice cream, graham cracker swirls, and chunks of chocolate! Come grab a scoop or a 1/2 gallon to go! Welcome to our 49th season at Plainwell Ice Cream, We’re open and ready to serve you!