Closed Monday. Tuesday - Sunday 12pm - 9pm

Plainwell Ice Cream Frequently Asked Questions

Check all frequently asked questions (faq) of Plainwell Ice Cream at this page. We are sure that you will get question answered from here. Thank you!

  • Do you ship your ice cream?

    No, unfortunately, we do not.

  • I’m interested in buying your ice cream for wholesale. Who should I contact?

    Please contact Dave Gaylord or Art Gaylord. They can be reached here info@plainwellicecreamco.com or by calling the ice cream store at (269) 685-8586.

  • What forms of payment do you accept?

    We accept cash, checks, Mastercard, Visa, and Discover. We do not accept American Express.

  • Do you make all your ice cream?

    Yes with the exception of the No Sugar Added ice cream and the Nondairy Sorbet.

  • Do you have any ice cream for people with dietary restrictions?

    We try to have two flavors of No Sugar Added ice cream at all times. Usually butter pecan and cherry vanilla. We also try to have 1 non-dairy sorbet. It is also vegan.

  • Does sherbet contain milk?

    Yes. Sherbet contains milk. Sorbet does not.

  • Can I order large quantities of ice cream for a special event?

    Yes. Please call us at (269) 685-8586 or email us at info@plainwellicecreamco.com. We will be happy to help.

  • Can I get 2 flavors in a cone?

    Yes! We are happy to put two flavors in either a small or large cone (or dish). No more please!

  • Do you make ice cream cakes?


  • Do you have soft serve ice cream?


  • Do you sell yogurt?